Have some friends going on a bachelor party in Key West next month (May). I’m thinking they should do some yellowtail/kingfishing/cobia/tarpon type of stuff (live bait fishing). I’ve done the offshore thing a few times and it’s not all that great compared to here.
Know any guides that can accommodate? 12 of them, so they’re going to need at least two boats, probably three…
Pat Condon
“Carla Dee”
They’ll need three boats inshore. 2 boats offshore.
I went inshore with Capt. Eric Bass out of Islamorada. He was fantastic. Bud and Mary’s Marina in Islamorada can fix you up with an offshore guide.
Carolina Skiff 17
50 Yamaha
You could also contact Capt. Ralph Delph or Capt. Rob Delph in Key West. If they can’t help you, I’m sure they’ll know someone who can.
Delph Fishing
305-294-4456
Tell Ralph that Jim Hester recommended you contact them. 
Dreamcatchers Charters has top notch boats and good guides.