I am gonna grill some dolphin tomorrow night and i have a craving for a good mater pie. Anyone have a good recipe for homemade tomato pie? My great grandma used to make a mean one but no one can seem to find her recipe since she passed.
cup mayo, cup cheese…mix the two together. layer maters, white onion, basil in pie shell, pour mixture on top. cover top with cheese, bake…i like mine w/ mozzerella.
I like to use a half/half mix of sour cream and mayo and shredded cheese. I also like to put in a bit of sriracha and italian seasonings. Don’t go shy on the tomatoes.
tomato shed cafe on johns island - their recipe is on the internet in a couple of places. Key point for them is they salt their tomato slices and leave them on a drying rack to get some of the moisture out. Other than that… you are dealing with pie crust, cheese, and tomatoes… hard to screw it up! 
Thanks guys
“Good things come to those who bait”
mhebbard hit the nail on the head. Lay the sliced tomatoes out on paper towels to get moisture out and be sure to peel them. I like to put slices of sharp cheddar on the bottom as the first layer.
Made one tonight fellas. Blackened some dolphin and grilled some squash, zucchini, and onions to go along with the dolphin and pie. All i got a picture of was the Mater pie. It turned out awesome. Thanks JMH. The pic is not that great.
[URL=http://s1327.photobucket.com/user/ReelHard/media/materpie_zps30b0d043.jpg.html]
[/URL]
Anyone know how to upload pics on here the right way?
“Good things come to those who bait”