Who do you folks believe is the GOAT and why?
I believe it is Montana… The why will come later if anyone decides to respond…
RBF
Montana
He would have had 3 in a row and 5 SBs easy if it weren’t for his injury. Who knows how many more the next 3-5 years of his career.
TB is great, but he has luck on his side with injury free seasons and great coaches for so many years.
Montana
Nicklaus
Jordan
Gretzky
The only GOATS in my book
“Wailord”
1979 17’ Montauk
90 Johnson
Wilderness Ride 115
quote:
Originally posted by GeronimoMontana
He would have had 3 in a row and 5 SBs easy if it weren’t for his injury. Who knows how many more the next 3-5 years of his career.
TB is great, but he has luck on his side with injury free seasons and great coaches for so many years.
Montana
Nicklaus
Jordan
GretzkyThe only GOATS in my book
“Wailord”
1979 17’ Montauk
90 JohnsonWilderness Ride 115
Agreed. Montana should have gotten the 1988 season SB MVP to add to his other 3, to make it 4-for-4 and match his winning record in SBs… Can’t believe they gave it Jerry Rice, no way he deserved it…
Montana also won his last SB under a different head coach and beat the Broncos 55-10… Look at the margin of victory with Brady’s SB wins… They are paltry… In addition, the quarterbacks Brady has faced in SB’s aren’t HOF caliber except KW with the Rams… Manning whipped Brady twice with the Giants… Montana beat Elway and Marino in SBs…
Finally, hitting the QB rules have changed dramatically since Montana… Under pressure of the old days when taking a QBs head off was allowed, Brady would cry like a little *****… He prolly wouldn’t have lasted more than 8-10 years…
The only person I would add to your list is obviously Babe Ruth…
RBF
George Blanda…dude could do it all…
Paul Crewe.
I’ll give it to Brady.
Montana had Rice to throw to, Brady has only really had one elite WR to throw to (Moss). Although I do think Rogers is the best QB in the NFL.
02’ Seapro 17’CC w/ 90 yamaha 2stroke
quote:
Originally posted by harrydPaul Crewe.
WINNER!! WINNER!!!
Mean Machine…
“…be a man and PM me.”
quote:
Originally posted by Clem1984I’ll give it to Brady.
Montana had Rice to throw to, Brady has only really had one elite WR to throw to (Moss). Although I do think Rogers is the best QB in the NFL.
02’ Seapro 17’CC w/ 90 yamaha 2stroke
Brady didn’t play with the likes of Lawrence Taylor either… Brady would collapse under the pressure in the pocket Montana endured…
It is a well known fact Brady chokes when he starts getting hit, and wouldn’t have survived in the Montana era with how the rules allowed actually hitting/dismantling a QB…
Just my biased opinion…
RBF
quote:
Originally posted by harrydPaul Crewe.
Nah… Paul Crewe was better in college under his original name…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5AAkhojA98
RBF
quote:
Originally posted by Area 51George Blanda…dude could do it all…
Yeah, sorta like this guy…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yy2TsTaH8Kk
RBF
Oh yeah… I forgot this one about Brady… He is a cheater…
Spygate and Deflategate… Montana did his winning straight-up…
RBF
Broadway Joe talking X’s and O’s with a skirt on the sideline…A HOF classic…
Aaron Rodgers and Peyton Manning (yeah, I know, I know… he chokes in the post season).
Unlike a tennis championship, Superbowls are won by teams and not individual players. There are times a team won because of a QB, and times a team won despite the QB.